Baseballs hot stove is warming up as teams look to upgrade their rosters before the expiration of the collective bargaining agreement on Dec. 1.Â
We’re waiting to see where this offseason’s top free agents, like two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal or star Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato will land. As more players come off the board, we’re grading notable deals and how they impact the teams involved.
JUMP TO: White Sox Ship Castillo | Garcia To Seattle | Twins Sign Gray | White Sox Sign May | Red Sox Sign Bauers | Braves Sign Phillips
Colorado receives: RHP Luis Castillo and RHP Davis MartinÂ
Chicago receives:Â LHP Sean Sullivan and minor-league C Douglas VelizÂ
Grade for Rockies: B-
Grade for White Sox: Incomplete
Breaking Down The Deal: This one came as a surprise, considering the White Sox just added Dustin May to try to bolster a rotation that was a weak spot last season. Now theyre taking two starting pitching options away. Its an acknowledgment of the mistake they made when they traded for Castillo at last seasons deadline, a move that seemed risky for a White Sox team that needed more reliability from its starting pitchers. At the time, Castillo had a 5.06 ERA, the lowest strikeout rate of his career, concerning underlying numbers and a contract few would have been willing to take on. The White Sox did it anyway, getting some salary relief by sending reliever Seranthony Dominguez back to Seattle along with a legitimate prospect in Boston Smith.Â
It all ended badly, as many feared, with Castillo registering an 8.42 ERA over nine appearances in Chicago and losing his spot in the White Sox rotation. Now, to move Castillos $22.75 million salary, they had to include a valuable big-league starter in Martin. Getting off the Castillo contract probably deserves a C here, but for now it gets an incomplete because this grade is entirely dependent on what the White Sox do with those savings. Neither Sullivan, a left-handed pitcher who debuted last year for the Rockies, nor Veliz, a 17-year-old catcher out of Venezuela whos more of a dart throw, are particularly highly-regarded prospects. The White Sox now must meaningfully upgrade the rotation with pieces better than Castillo and Martin.Â
The Rockies were going to have their hands full convincing starting pitchers to go to Colorado on the open market, so its possible the additions of Castillo and Martin were better than anything they could have done in free agency. Castillo is coming off the worst season of his career and just allowed the highest pulled fly ball rate of his career â not a great sign as he heads to Coors Field! â but he is a three-time All-Star who had produced an ERA under 4.00 in seven straight seasons before his 2026 implosion. The bigger get is Martin, who had an All-Star caliber first half for the White Sox (9-4, 3.41 ERA) before free-falling in the second half (0-4, 5.12). Martins 45.1% hard-hit rate last year could spell trouble in Colorado, but he finished the year with a 3.95 ERA and he represents an upgrade for a Rockies pitching staff that needs all the help it can get. – Kavner
Seattle receives: 3B Maikel Garcia, RHP James McArthur and a minor league relieverÂ
Kansas City receives: RHP Bryce Miller, LHP Jose Ferrer and RHP Logan Evans
Grade for Mariners: A-
Grade for Royals: C
Breaking Down

