One of the defining images of 2020 featured two homeowners, two firearms and a confrontation that ignited a national firestorm.
Six years later, the legal, political and cultural fallout from that moment continues to reverberate through debates over self-defense, private rights, public protest and prosecutorial power.
On June 28, 2020, as racial justice protests swept cities across America following the death of , Black Lives Matter demonstrators made their way through Portland Place, a private, gated street in St. Louis, toward the home of then-Mayor Lyda Krewson.
As the crowd passed through the neighborhood, the McCloskeys emerged from their home carrying firearms â Mark with an AR-15-style rifle and Patricia with a handgun. Within hours, images of the encounter had spread nationwide, turning a confrontation on a private St. Louis street into a flashpoint in America’s debate over self-defense, property rights and public protest.
Supporters viewed the couple as homeowners defending their property during a period of unrest that had swept cities across the country. Critics argued they unnecessarily escalated the situation by .
Six years later, the legal and political aftershocks of that day are still being felt.
ð¨ Have a tip about crime, public safety, or an issue impacting your community?
ð© Email: stepheny.price@fox.com
ð¸ Instagram: @fndstephprice
ð¥ X: @StephenyPrice
Whether it’s a developing case, concerning trend, or something you think deserves attention, your information could help lead our next story or investigation.
Looking back today, Mark McCloskey said the experience reinforced one lesson above all else.
“You can’t rely on others,” McCloskey told Fox News Digital. “You have to be prepared. You have to know how to defend yourself.”
One of the latest developments came in 2025, when he announced that his after what he described as three lawsuits, two trips to the Missouri Court of Appeals and more than 1,800 days of litigation.
“It only took 3 lawsuits, 2 trips to the Court of Appeals and 1,847 days, but I got my AR15 back!” McCloskey wrote on social media after recovering the rifle.
Looking back, McCloskey said the yearslong legal battle reinforced the value of perseverance.
“It teaches the benefit of perseverance,” he said. “It took me 1,847 days, three lawsuits and two trips to the Court of Appeals to get my rifle back and then another 60 days or so to get that pistol back.”
He said the ordeal also took a significant toll on the couple’s law practice.
“Our business was relatively destroyed,” McCloskey said. “If you Googled the McCloskey Law Center for two years after that event or longer, it said ‘permanently closed.’ If you Google my name right now it still says Mark McCloskey is a former personal injury lawyer. Nobody told me I retired.”
The legal battle over the firearms was only the latest chapter in a saga that quickly expanded far beyond the confrontation itself.
Then-St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kim Gardner charged the couple with unlawful use of a weapon, triggering a closely watched legal fight that drew national attention. Then-Missouri Attorney General Eric Schmitt criticized the prosecution and sought to intervene, arguing the case raised broader questions about Missourians’ rights to defend themselves and their property.
Looking back six years later, Schmitt, now a Missouri senator, said the case reflected what he believes was a broader trend among progressive prosecutors during that period.
“As rioters razed St. Louis, activist prosecutors like Kim Gardner chose to go after law-abid

