NFL trade deadline day didn’t spark a ton of fireworks, but plenty of fireworks were shot off in the days and weeks leading up to Tuesday.
Of the deals that were made on deadline day, though, none were bigger than the Minnesota Vikings’ decision to reunite with Kirk Cousins. The Vikings gave up a third-round pick to land Cousins from the Las Vegas Raiders as their quarterback struggles were clearly holding them back.Â
Other moves, like the massive trades the Jacksonville Jaguars made on Monday or the deal the Chicago Bears swung two weeks ago, could define this season’s homestretch and postseason. And on the flip side, the Indianapolis Colts and Philadelphia Eagles waved the white flag on the season, securing major draft capital.Â
So, what should we make of the biggest trade deadline deals? Who won and lost the trade deadline? We asked those questions to general managers, executives and scouts around the league. Here’s what we learned.Â
Eric D. Williams:Â While giving Minnesota props for securing a quality quarterback at the trade deadline, an NFL contract negotiator also questioned the teams personnel department in evaluating previous quarterback decisions and their fit in head coach Kevin OConnells system.
“Its crazy how expectations can spiral so quickly,” the league source told me. “And I mean this more so in regard to Kyler Murray. Going into the season, the expectation was that Kyler was the high-ceiling QB who could return OConnells offense to prominence. But from a pro scouting standpoint, the Minnesota front office clearly missed. And now theyre without a third-round pick.
“Good for them for cutting their losses and acquiring Cousins, but its clear that the Murray signing [while not costing them hardly any money] was a swing and a miss.”
The contract negotiator sees Cousins as a clear upgrade, but questioned whether the 38-year-old can stay healthy enough to help lead the Vikings on a deep postseason run, considering his past injury history.
“Im not going to discredit what Cousins can do for Minnesota,” the league source told me. “With how that defense is playing, Cousins acquisition could also fall in the shooting our shot bucket.
“They just need him to be competent in KOCs offense. They dont need him to play hero ball. If he can just run the offense, then theyll have a chance. But yes, health is a concern.”
Another league source told me Daniel Jones would have been a better fit if available, but overall liked the trade.
“I wish they could have picked up Daniel, but I understand their thinking,” the league source said. “And if the MNF game had gone well, they would not have done anything.“
Ralph Vacchiano: For the most part, this is being viewed as a classic win-win trade, to varying degrees.
For the Vikings, the win is obvious: They found what might be the perfect starting QB for them, and it “only” cost them a third-round pick.Â
“I mean, they were desperate,” one NFL general manager told me. “They were calling everybody. And they had to do it. [Kyler] Murray and [Carson] Wentz had been terrible. They were going to cost them a real chance at a Super Bowl. I wouldve held out for a second, at least, and I think they wouldve had to pay it. They werent coming out of this without a quarterback.”
They also got what another NFL executive told me was the “perfect guy for them” â a former Viking who knows Kevin OConnells offense and No. 1 wide receiver Justin Jefferson and wont need long to get up to speed.Â
“If you think about it, its kind of a miracle,” the executive told me. “The right guy at the right price, and hes available halfway through the season. What are the odds it works out like that?”
As for the Raiders, the general manager summed up their win like this: “They got a 3 for a guy they were going to bench soon anyway. Maybe they have to turn to Fernando Mendoza (their rookie No. 1

