Ordering isn’t always cut and dry.
With different cuts, grades and preparations to consider, it’s easy to get something other than what you expected â or even other than what you’re paying for.
An Illinois man recently went viral after for serving him a cheaper sirloin instead of a filet mignon on three separate visits. The chain only confirmed one incident and said management corrected it, but the episode struck a nerve online: many people realized they wouldn’t even know the difference between the two.
EXPERTS REVEAL HOW TO SPOT FAKE ‘WAGYU’ SO YOU DON’T GET RIPPED OFF ON PREMIUM BEEF
Experts shared with Fox News Digital what diners should expect from popular steak cuts, how to decode menu terms and what to ask their server.
Katie Flannery, a third-generation butcher at Northern California’s Flannery Beef, calls filet, rib-eye and New York strip the “holy trinity” of steak cuts. Choosing among them comes down to what a diner wants most.Â
Filet mignon is a good choice for tenderness because it comes from a muscle that gets little use. It has less inherent flavor than other popular cuts and is usually the most expensive, in part because only a small amount comes from each animal.
For a beefier flavor, Flannery recommends rib-eye.Â
MEAT EXPERT SHARES THE MISTAKE MOST AMERICANS MAKE WHEN COOKING STEAK
“Just know it’ll have a little bit more chew than a filet,” she said.
John Tesar, executive chef of Palladino’s Steak & Seafood in New York City and Dallas, describes the rib-eye as having a tender center and a more flavorful, sturdier outer section.Â
“You get a tender inner circle and a sturdier, more flavorful outside, all supported by fat,” he said.
A New York strip, meanwhile, is recognizable by the band of fat along one side and has a heartier texture. Flannery said it has less flavor than a rib-eye and, depending on its grade, can have more chew than a filet.
That leaves the porterhouse, which includes both a New York strip and a filet on one bone and is often large enough to share.
Some menu terms can make it all more confusing, experts noted. A “sirloin filet” may be sirloin shaped to look like filet mignon. Sirloin comes from the more-used hip and rump, making it less tender than filet.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) grades offer another clue and reflect a steak’s marbling, or flecks of fat within the muscle, which contributes to flavor and tenderness. The main grades are Prime, the top grade, Choice and Select.
Filet, rib-eye, New York strip and sirloin can all come from Prime, Choice or Select beef. The USDA grades the carcass, so cuts from that carcass share its grade, according to the agency. Grading is voluntary, so some beef is ungraded.
Flannery said about 10% of graded cattle earn the Prime designation, while about 70% qualify as Choice. Prime has more marbling than Choice or Select.
WHY HOMEMADE PRIME RIB CAN BE ‘EVEN BETTER’ THAN AT A STEAKHOUSE, EXPERTS SAY
“Fat is flavor, honestly,” she said.Â
More marbling can contribute to flavor and tenderness, but it is only one factor. “The more the muscle moved in the animal’s lifetime, the tougher it is,” Flannery said.
Both wet- and dry-aging can improve tenderness, while dry-aging concentrates flavor, Flannery said.
Wet-aging i

