We’ve had two weeks of the College Football Playoff selection committee’s top-25 poll, and two weeks of well-deserved controversy over their rankings. And the controversy extends well past just the positions each team sits, to the reasoning behind it.
Both weeks have had one consistent theme: the SEC has received an enormous, and undeserved, boost for their teams. Losses don’t count for as much in the SEC, while every win is assumed to be a “quality” one. Injuries are given more deference, and preseason expectations are still treated as meaningful.
All while teams in other conferences are punished for … not playing. Like the Indiana Hoosiers, who dropped five spots in the rankings from No. 4 to No. 9 while on a bye week.
HERE’S HOW BAD THE COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF’S SELECTION COMMITTEE RANKINGS ACTUALLY ARE
Head coach Curt Cignetti, the defending national champion, brought up how many other coaches are thinking and feeling about the poll in a Monday press conference. Roasting the selection committee for the disparate treatment and how they handle losses and wins dependent on brand names, stadiums, and marketing efforts, not team quality.
“You get tired of the narrative sometimes,” Cignetti said. “A quality win because Joe Smith was playing at the time. They aint won a game since, but it was a quality win back then. I guess bad losses dont count. Look, its all going to play out on the field. Its good for entertainment. Im sure thisll get a lot of nice hits and play.
“But our guys understand that itll play out on the field. The good thing about it is, I think it feeds into our motivation and our chip. Thats why Im not afraid to keep it alive. And you know what? Im 65 years old and I really dont give a s–t.”
How the committee handled Cignetti’s Indiana team is one thing. How they justify it is another. And that justification is why the committee faces a major test of their legitimacy and remaining shreds of credibility.
NEW COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF POLL PROVES THE SELECTION COMMITTEE IS JUST MAKING IT UP AS THEY GO
During committee chair Hunter Yurachek’s post-release interview, he “explained” why the Hoosiers fell five spots without playing.
“Indiana was probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time with seven games between Top 25 teams,” he said. “The committee is really impressed with what UCLA, Texas, and Notre Dame did as well as Alabama and LSU.”
“Every team that Indiana had played to date in the Big Ten all lost and that affected their strength of schedule rank and the committee’s review of Indiana,” he continued. “The quarterback play in general and the offensive play in general is kind of a discussion point of Indiana … They’ve won games because of their defense and n

